The latest instalment in the Captain America franchise brings Sam Wilson to the forefront while continuing the legacy of the shield. As the first solo outing for him as Captain America, the film attempts to establish a fresh direction for the character while maintaining the high-stakes action and moral dilemmas that have defined the series. However, despite its ambition, the film struggles to find its footing, hindered by lacklustre execution in several key areas.
One of the most glaring issues is some of the green screen usage. While Marvel films have always leaned heavily on CGI, this film felt particularly artificial at times, with certain scenes clearly suffering from poor compositing and an overreliance on digital backdrops. It’s especially noticeable where reshoots took place, as the lighting in some scenes is visibly different, making it obvious when certain sequences were reworked. This inconsistency is not just visual but extends to the storytelling, where changes and reshot material stand out, affecting the film’s overall flow.
The film’s villain(s) fail to leave a lasting impression. A compelling antagonist is crucial to any superhero story, but here, the threat feels generic and uninspired. There’s little depth or motivation beyond surface-level conflict, making the stakes feel artificial rather than genuinely gripping. For a film meant to redefine Captain America’s role in the MCU, a more developed and engaging antagonist was sorely needed. The mind control shtick has been done enough in the MCU, maybe it was time for something new?
Dialogue is another weak point. The script is riddled with corny lines that feel out of place, undermining moments that should have carried more weight. While some humour is expected in Marvel films, the balance here is off—many lines that should have been delivered with gravitas instead come off as awkward or forced.
That said, the film isn’t without its strengths. The action sequences do deliver some thrilling moments. When practical effects and well-choreographed fight scenes take centre stage, the film shines, reminding audiences why Captain America’s combat style is so compelling.
One of the more intriguing aspects of the film is its exploration of the celestial element of the MCU. Seeing more of the universe’s larger-than-life creature is a welcome addition. While this element isn’t fully fleshed out, it hints at exciting possibilities for future instalments.
Overall, the new Captain America movie is a mixed bag. While it has its moments of excitement and potential, the weak villain, bad green screen hold it back from reaching the heights of its predecessors. Fans of the franchise may find some enjoyment in the action and world-building, but as a whole, the film fails to make the impact it should have. Any Marvel fan will watch this film no matter what, but someone outside of that niche? You may still have a good time.
In a grander outlook, the Avergers movies at coming very soon and it does not feel like it whilst watching the films, there is limited connected tissue these days, in an era that should be bringing elements together, connecting them in an overarching theme to get fans and viewers ready for the immense scale that is the next two Avengers films.